The specific example I gave just before was - probably more the former.
[ he is not sure he wants to claim "fucked up by bro" as an identity. but it isn't a thing he can just make go away by wanting it really badly.
dave bites his lip, but it's less a worried gesture and more a stall for time as he messes with it. ]
I...think that... [ the stall didn't go on long enough because he's not sure how to explain the new thought he's had, so dave just. shrugs again, changing gears and leaving whatever-it-was behind for the moment. ] It's not a problem unique to you. I made myself into someone else for a lot of reasons for a long time, but "keeping other people happy" was always...a huge factor? I didn't try to change anything quite so - ok, well I guess technically I ignored anything to do with. That. On the grounds it was - honestly we can get into that later, but mostly I - ignored the part where I wasn't...you know.
Things like that are things we can work on together, the way we've worked on flashstepping and are going to try with puppets.
[He hopes it is more of the former, but he worries. Not that Dave will take it as an identity, he's sure it isn't. But because he worries about Dave refusing to admit discomfort for fear of changing Dirk.]
Is it... the thing you were going to say. What were you going to start with? I think I got the 'you know' on the second part of it.
[There have been a lot of those and Dirk is trying to track them.]
It's...an idea I had before but which didn't last for the space of one conversation. I don't know if I want you to tear it down or build it up. And I'm still not sure if it's...
[He wonders if it is the idea that Dave had talking to Komaeda, which was crushed like two seconds later.]
I can wait for a little. Until you are ready to try to talk about it.
[He thinks that's okay. It's true, at the least. He can wait.]
I assumed that whereas I tried to stop being exclusively attracted to dudes, you tried to stop not actually being happy about growing up in an abusive household.
Got it in one. I was really good at it, I'll have you know? None of them suspected a fuckin' thing. I mean, they thought Bro was weird because I couldn't really sell the puppet thing as like...well they all thought that was creepy. But even the people who literally got to see that bullshit in realtime bought my story, you know? Terezi thought I was mourning him when I found his body.
[ maybe he was? it was more shock than anything else, though. he hadn't liked bro, but bro had been unbeatable and it was just...sure a thing. to realize he'd never get any sort of closure, he'd never measure up because the measuring stick had broken, and there was no chance of anything at all. ]
Then I met you and actually talked about shit. I'm holdin' you responsible.
[ the thing he keeps coming back to is "maybe it is okay that i am sometimes not okay and am upset?" and yes komaeda sure did. backtrack that idea real fast. ]
The stupid thing is I was so sure for half a minute no one could take that stupid-ass idea away from me and then it was like no, you're being dumb and broken and unreasonable again, Dave. Duh. Hey, want to read that stunning journey into my psyche as well? All idiotic things come in threes. Though I'm pretty sure I was just...all over in the wrong there. I'm probably still in the wrong right now.
I'm willing to own up to my part in talking about things, since I consider it the opposite of a negative, but I'd say that it was your strength and the support of the people who loved you on the meteor who got us to that point first.
[So that's where he stands there. This is... not about how Dirk handles saying 'no' but it's not like any of their conversations ever travel linearly so Dirk just. Mentally bookmarks that and decides to come back to it later. As it is, he isn't sure what the conversation is, but]
Sure, I'll read it.
[Dave's out-of-context comment would actually give Dirk its context, so yes.]
[ dave circles back around to topics when he decides on an emotion for them or a question. it's one of his most annoying habits probably. dirk deserves someone who can converse in a straight line? and yet?
he just sends over another conversation which will be the last one because three is a nice number.
then he promptly goes back to the previous topic after giving dirk that without giving dirk time to respond on that topic, because that is how he operates sometimes. ]
So what else about you is intrinsic to your person by your standards?
You probably shouldn't hand me one of the most complicated questions in philosophy while also giving me something to read.
[Which he will in a second, but he also isn't sure about things. And he looks at Dave, that level of unsure. That level of... not knowing.
The path of the self sucks.]
There are things I thought were essentially true about myself, but which my splinters could call into question. Like... I don't know if the universe would agree that something about me can be an essential part of my identity if it wasn't in your Bro's identity. It seems misguided to count those things as immutable when they are, in fact, mutations of the original version of me.
I honestly don't know. Some of the things that aren't true about him are things that I value in myself and that I'd like to work on being better at. But maybe they aren't essential to what Dirk Strider is.
[ zero apologies for making dirk consider a hard question, dirk and rose ask them all the time. ]
Technically, he wasn't the original version. That is, none of us were. The babies who had a myriad jumble of whatifs depending on when and where and what the fuckever were the originals. Callin' one timeline an "original" is kinda difficult when there are so many dead end versions. The original should be a term used for the source, right? Not the iteration.
[ ..............that has nothing to do with anything ]
I guess my question is: do you know what it is you aren't willing or able to change about yourself? ...And what did you used to think was true about yourself and what do you value in yourself. Those are questions I have, too.
You're getting even more ruthless than usual, dude.
[So many hard questions. Hm.
Dirk cannot steal an apple from the branches, so he goes for a random leaf. He traces over its veins with the pad of his thumb, and when he speaks, he speaks slowly.] One thing, that I've thought to be true all of my life, even as I feared I did it wrong, and that your Bro feels like he calls into question, is simply that I love my friends. I've been afraid that I don't love them properly or that my emotions are corrupted and self-interested, and I've been afraid of my love as something corrosive and toxic. At the same time, love and loyalty towards them, and now to you and Rose, is something I'd never want to lose. Even if, apparently, one version of me wasn't capable of loving anyone at all.
Does it... [He stops again. He rephrases.] Do you understand why I'm worried that maybe love and loyalty aren't an essential part of me, and maybe are somehow... fake? Even though it doesn't feel fake, at times I worry about it. I worry that I'm just the emotionless, rational machine everyone seems to see me as. That, I guess, some splinter of me was.
[ though he hadn't been aware that specifically was a thing dirk feared. he knew dirk was worried about what was or was not bro about himself, but the emotionless rational machine had...not ever been a thing dave had really been able to comprehend. the nearest dirk had ever gotten to tripping him into seeing bro was telling dave he was overreacting to the reaper thing. and even then he hadn't been halfway there. ]
It isn't fake? I can tell you that much. If it were, I'd be able to tell, and I...wouldn't be talkin' to you about any of this. [ he tries to consider what it would have been like to meet bro as a teen, and how he would have dealt with that. with him being here, and -
dave stops trying to consider that. ]
When I've worried about you...not feeling that way any longer, it's never had to do with that particular reasoning behind it. About you...not caring about people and things. Also, you're as irrational as I am a lot of the time so I guess it never occurred to me to worry that you were like...too rational?
[ ... ]
I know what it feels like to worry about loving people well, too.
It's occurred to me lately, Dave, that you have the most skewed perspective of me of anyone in the world. You probably think I'm easy to make laugh.
[It's reassuring, what Dave said, and he thinks he knows what the ellipses was. Still, it amuses him in its way. Dave has such a peculiar and unique image of him. Dirk's friends at least understand that Dirk comes off differently from how he is. Dave seems to think that Dirk is the same with him as he is with everyone.]
It's a kinda perpetual concern. I already told you that the people I love most are the ones I've done the most damage to. But I can't... not love them. It's still difficult for me to understand how he was incapable of love. None of the external factors seem to account for it, so it feels like it follows that maybe me caring is the anomaly.
[Like there are important personal things to get here but first]
Dave. I'm pretty sure Karkat and Rin are running a competition right now to see who can make me smile first. It has been running for months, from what I can tell. Neither of them have managed even that.
Most people can't read me, on the grounds that most people aren't accustomed to trying to read the facial expressions of an infant who grew up with little real in-person social interaction. The reason everyone thinks you're more readable than I am is that you emote more obviously. It's a misreading of you, since they seem to miss that you're a better liar than I am, but it's still the general impression..
Even setting that aside, I think the last time I laughed near Rin was maybe August. Pretty sure I haven't actually smiled near... almost everyone we've ever had on base. The truth is that I'm not expressive, and very few people actually get enough of an emotional reaction out of me to trigger a physical response. You're uniquely skilled at getting me to smile or laugh. The way I act around you in general is unique to us, which I think should be obvious if you reflect on how you've seen me behave towards others.
[How often has he seen Dirk smile at others? How often has he seen Dirk unfold, fully relaxed, near someone else? Move closer to have proximity, initiate physical contact, spend hours talking to just because?
It's an infrequent event for anyone off a short list. Even Roxy and Jake, whom Dirk loves and adores, don't make him laugh at the rate Dave does, and the body language around them has always been different—cautious and loving always, and yes he is relaxed by them, wants to be near to them, talk and have contact with them. But he is frightened of different mistakes and eager for different kinds of affection and it expresses itself in the physicality he has around them. Though he loves them no less, it is different because the relationships are different. The way he acts around Dave really is absolutely unique.]
[ look. it's hard being the only cause of canon on screen dirk strider smiles, what the fuck even is that, hussie. dave would argue the better liar thing, and might still, but he actually pauses to think about it because he agreed to, you know, try to listen. ]
You emote about the same amount as me around other people. I just had to learn to like...
[ ...uh. ]
It sounds bad if I say I learned to smile more in order to keep people from in-person asking questions, doesn't it. Once we met up in person, they actually needed somethin' there to read. But you are so expressive. It's just not a kind of expression most people have had to learn, I guess.
[ he's not sure how they got here. ]
You said we should talk about when we need one another to say no. I'm...not sure what my list would look like. What do you need me to say no to?
[This is a joke which hopefully Dave will realize. DIRK HAS. Come to accept being the weirdest person in expressions.]
I think we should go back and establish whether or not either of us capable of saying 'no' first. That was what we were discussing, when I started talking about my identity and the things that are immutable.
[ and before dave gave him that komaeda conversation he PROMPTLY DISTRACTED DIRK FROM ]
When I think saying yes would hurt you or someone else, I can say no.
[ it's a clearer answer than he had given earlier. ]
I...don't do so seriously usually otherwise? It's not like I'm always unhappy with whatever and more often than not I'd say it's more a case of I frequently don't really care what I do with someone, but I'm more likely to do shit I don't care about or don't want to do if asked by the right person. I've said no to keep you from getting pissed off at me for saying yes, too.
[Dave may or may not think he distracted Dirk BUT IN FACT]
In the sense that you have decided not to do a thing you didn't want to, because you knew I'd know you didn't want to, and wouldn't want you to do what you wouldn't want to do.
Minority versus majority. I don't think it really...matters? Like, clearly my feelings on that matter were fucked up and don't really count, and even if they did, so what? I can't do anything about the situation beyond ignore it and keep to myself and away from everyone involved in it. And that's probably the correct thing? Like...I can't impose my feelings on other people especially when they're dumb as fuck. I removed myself from the entire debacle as the one in the wrong and it seems to be workin' out for all of them so far, so like. Whatever?
[ he spreads his hands palm-up, shrugging. ]
I can at least maybe kind of expect to be like...safe and shit. In my own living space. Or, well, maybe that's also not a thing I am supposed to be able to have, but I can at least - probably do that? It was unreasonable to have the expectations I did previously re: the base, and also I clearly like. Overreacted by minding in the ways I did, or. Yeah.
With Komaeda, you said to him that it was okay for you not to be okay with it. Specifically, that you're allowed to not be okay with it and not to trust them. Now, it sounds like you don't believe that.
[The way Dave once sounded like he was sure it didn't matter and it was his Bro's fault, and now he thinks maybe it's his own fault.]
no subject
[dirk no]
Are you talking about changing your habits and behavior, or changing your identity?
no subject
[ he is not sure he wants to claim "fucked up by bro" as an identity. but it isn't a thing he can just make go away by wanting it really badly.
dave bites his lip, but it's less a worried gesture and more a stall for time as he messes with it. ]
I...think that... [ the stall didn't go on long enough because he's not sure how to explain the new thought he's had, so dave just. shrugs again, changing gears and leaving whatever-it-was behind for the moment. ] It's not a problem unique to you. I made myself into someone else for a lot of reasons for a long time, but "keeping other people happy" was always...a huge factor? I didn't try to change anything quite so - ok, well I guess technically I ignored anything to do with. That. On the grounds it was - honestly we can get into that later, but mostly I - ignored the part where I wasn't...you know.
[ YOU KNOW!!!!! ]
no subject
[He hopes it is more of the former, but he worries. Not that Dave will take it as an identity, he's sure it isn't. But because he worries about Dave refusing to admit discomfort for fear of changing Dirk.]
Is it... the thing you were going to say. What were you going to start with? I think I got the 'you know' on the second part of it.
[There have been a lot of those and Dirk is trying to track them.]
no subject
[ ... ]
What did you think the "you know" part was?
no subject
I can wait for a little. Until you are ready to try to talk about it.
[He thinks that's okay. It's true, at the least. He can wait.]
I assumed that whereas I tried to stop being exclusively attracted to dudes, you tried to stop not actually being happy about growing up in an abusive household.
no subject
[ maybe he was? it was more shock than anything else, though. he hadn't liked bro, but bro had been unbeatable and it was just...sure a thing. to realize he'd never get any sort of closure, he'd never measure up because the measuring stick had broken, and there was no chance of anything at all. ]
Then I met you and actually talked about shit. I'm holdin' you responsible.
[ the thing he keeps coming back to is "maybe it is okay that i am sometimes not okay and am upset?" and yes komaeda sure did. backtrack that idea real fast. ]
The stupid thing is I was so sure for half a minute no one could take that stupid-ass idea away from me and then it was like no, you're being dumb and broken and unreasonable again, Dave. Duh. Hey, want to read that stunning journey into my psyche as well? All idiotic things come in threes. Though I'm pretty sure I was just...all over in the wrong there. I'm probably still in the wrong right now.
no subject
[So that's where he stands there. This is... not about how Dirk handles saying 'no' but it's not like any of their conversations ever travel linearly so Dirk just. Mentally bookmarks that and decides to come back to it later. As it is, he isn't sure what the conversation is, but]
Sure, I'll read it.
[Dave's out-of-context comment would actually give Dirk its context, so yes.]
no subject
he just sends over another conversation which will be the last one because three is a nice number.
then he promptly goes back to the previous topic after giving dirk that without giving dirk time to respond on that topic, because that is how he operates sometimes. ]
So what else about you is intrinsic to your person by your standards?
[ time to multitask, dirk. ]
no subject
[Which he will in a second, but he also isn't sure about things. And he looks at Dave, that level of unsure. That level of... not knowing.
The path of the self sucks.]
There are things I thought were essentially true about myself, but which my splinters could call into question. Like... I don't know if the universe would agree that something about me can be an essential part of my identity if it wasn't in your Bro's identity. It seems misguided to count those things as immutable when they are, in fact, mutations of the original version of me.
I honestly don't know. Some of the things that aren't true about him are things that I value in myself and that I'd like to work on being better at. But maybe they aren't essential to what Dirk Strider is.
no subject
[ zero apologies for making dirk consider a hard question, dirk and rose ask them all the time. ]
Technically, he wasn't the original version. That is, none of us were. The babies who had a myriad jumble of whatifs depending on when and where and what the fuckever were the originals. Callin' one timeline an "original" is kinda difficult when there are so many dead end versions. The original should be a term used for the source, right? Not the iteration.
[ ..............that has nothing to do with anything ]
I guess my question is: do you know what it is you aren't willing or able to change about yourself? ...And what did you used to think was true about yourself and what do you value in yourself. Those are questions I have, too.
no subject
[So many hard questions. Hm.
Dirk cannot steal an apple from the branches, so he goes for a random leaf. He traces over its veins with the pad of his thumb, and when he speaks, he speaks slowly.] One thing, that I've thought to be true all of my life, even as I feared I did it wrong, and that your Bro feels like he calls into question, is simply that I love my friends. I've been afraid that I don't love them properly or that my emotions are corrupted and self-interested, and I've been afraid of my love as something corrosive and toxic. At the same time, love and loyalty towards them, and now to you and Rose, is something I'd never want to lose. Even if, apparently, one version of me wasn't capable of loving anyone at all.
Does it... [He stops again. He rephrases.] Do you understand why I'm worried that maybe love and loyalty aren't an essential part of me, and maybe are somehow... fake? Even though it doesn't feel fake, at times I worry about it. I worry that I'm just the emotionless, rational machine everyone seems to see me as. That, I guess, some splinter of me was.
no subject
[ though he hadn't been aware that specifically was a thing dirk feared. he knew dirk was worried about what was or was not bro about himself, but the emotionless rational machine had...not ever been a thing dave had really been able to comprehend. the nearest dirk had ever gotten to tripping him into seeing bro was telling dave he was overreacting to the reaper thing. and even then he hadn't been halfway there. ]
It isn't fake? I can tell you that much. If it were, I'd be able to tell, and I...wouldn't be talkin' to you about any of this. [ he tries to consider what it would have been like to meet bro as a teen, and how he would have dealt with that. with him being here, and -
dave stops trying to consider that. ]
When I've worried about you...not feeling that way any longer, it's never had to do with that particular reasoning behind it. About you...not caring about people and things. Also, you're as irrational as I am a lot of the time so I guess it never occurred to me to worry that you were like...too rational?
[ ... ]
I know what it feels like to worry about loving people well, too.
no subject
[It's reassuring, what Dave said, and he thinks he knows what the ellipses was. Still, it amuses him in its way. Dave has such a peculiar and unique image of him. Dirk's friends at least understand that Dirk comes off differently from how he is. Dave seems to think that Dirk is the same with him as he is with everyone.]
It's a kinda perpetual concern. I already told you that the people I love most are the ones I've done the most damage to. But I can't... not love them. It's still difficult for me to understand how he was incapable of love. None of the external factors seem to account for it, so it feels like it follows that maybe me caring is the anomaly.
no subject
[ his brow furrows. ]
You laugh all the fuckin' time. And I don't know if I'd say that's the anomaly. Like - Dirk, you're really different, in more than just that way.
no subject
Dave. I'm pretty sure Karkat and Rin are running a competition right now to see who can make me smile first. It has been running for months, from what I can tell. Neither of them have managed even that.
no subject
[ look ]
And even if you don't it's not like you look, like...emotionless. I have seen you around base without me, you know. Your expressions exist?
[ he. may also consider the tiniest quirk of a lip or relaxing of dirk's neutral expression to be "happy" because...they are???? ]
Didn't know abut the bet, but Vantas tends not to tell me that kinda thing so it ain't too surprisin'.
no subject
Even setting that aside, I think the last time I laughed near Rin was maybe August. Pretty sure I haven't actually smiled near... almost everyone we've ever had on base. The truth is that I'm not expressive, and very few people actually get enough of an emotional reaction out of me to trigger a physical response. You're uniquely skilled at getting me to smile or laugh. The way I act around you in general is unique to us, which I think should be obvious if you reflect on how you've seen me behave towards others.
[How often has he seen Dirk smile at others? How often has he seen Dirk unfold, fully relaxed, near someone else? Move closer to have proximity, initiate physical contact, spend hours talking to just because?
It's an infrequent event for anyone off a short list. Even Roxy and Jake, whom Dirk loves and adores, don't make him laugh at the rate Dave does, and the body language around them has always been different—cautious and loving always, and yes he is relaxed by them, wants to be near to them, talk and have contact with them. But he is frightened of different mistakes and eager for different kinds of affection and it expresses itself in the physicality he has around them. Though he loves them no less, it is different because the relationships are different. The way he acts around Dave really is absolutely unique.]
no subject
You emote about the same amount as me around other people. I just had to learn to like...
[ ...uh. ]
It sounds bad if I say I learned to smile more in order to keep people from in-person asking questions, doesn't it. Once we met up in person, they actually needed somethin' there to read. But you are so expressive. It's just not a kind of expression most people have had to learn, I guess.
[ he's not sure how they got here. ]
You said we should talk about when we need one another to say no. I'm...not sure what my list would look like. What do you need me to say no to?
no subject
[This is a joke which hopefully Dave will realize. DIRK HAS. Come to accept being the weirdest person in expressions.]
I think we should go back and establish whether or not either of us capable of saying 'no' first. That was what we were discussing, when I started talking about my identity and the things that are immutable.
[in case dave forgot]
no subject
When I think saying yes would hurt you or someone else, I can say no.
[ it's a clearer answer than he had given earlier. ]
I...don't do so seriously usually otherwise? It's not like I'm always unhappy with whatever and more often than not I'd say it's more a case of I frequently don't really care what I do with someone, but I'm more likely to do shit I don't care about or don't want to do if asked by the right person. I've said no to keep you from getting pissed off at me for saying yes, too.
no subject
In the sense that you have decided not to do a thing you didn't want to, because you knew I'd know you didn't want to, and wouldn't want you to do what you wouldn't want to do.
Damn. That sounds so stupid.
[They're stupid.]
What about to Komaeda?
no subject
[ so he like. still. tried...to do the dumb thing...and dirk wouldn't allow it... ]
What about to Komaeda? That whole situation is...different.
no subject
[Dave why...]
How is Komaeda different?
no subject
[ he spreads his hands palm-up, shrugging. ]
I can at least maybe kind of expect to be like...safe and shit. In my own living space. Or, well, maybe that's also not a thing I am supposed to be able to have, but I can at least - probably do that? It was unreasonable to have the expectations I did previously re: the base, and also I clearly like. Overreacted by minding in the ways I did, or. Yeah.
no subject
[The way Dave once sounded like he was sure it didn't matter and it was his Bro's fault, and now he thinks maybe it's his own fault.]
What made you change your perspective?
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
...
...
...
...
...