All of the above. John's oblivious, but he isn't a complete idiot. All he really has to do is talk to the right troll about the wrong shit. I told you they had viewports, right? And unfettered access to our personal timelines. So - gossip wouldn't even require you or Rose or Vantas to break faith.
[ just...you know, any of the various trolls he has Not explained his life to. ]
I probably don't need to worry about what I would with you. Like - if you hadn't known, you could...set me off, but John...
[ how to put it. ]
Bein' around him is like gettin' a straight shot of pure energy towards exactly what you always try to tear down. [ it's like being thirteen again and being around john makes it feel easy, the lies coming second-nature. ] If he never finds out...I don't know. I guess I'd just feel like crap sometimes for not tellin' him, but that's nothin' new and not comparable, I guess?
Sixteen years. On the meteor I like, thought about the things I did and why I did them. But I never talked about it. It was sixteen years of the same old mask.
Sometimes this feels easy with you or Rose. [ sometimes. in the good moments, once or twice in a desperately bad moment. on occasion, it comes easier than it has before. ] But usually it's very, very difficult.
[ deliberately going against his past. ]
But I don't think I'd be happy doing things the easy way with you, even if I've tried.
We both know I wouldn't be happy. It's gratifying you aren't either. [Which... is maybe terrible? Shit. Is it terrible. Or is it good.
He doesn't know.]
Ignoring whether or not that was fucked up of me to think, what's the worst case scenario for you telling John? Without visualizing it. [No panic attack.]
[Since he'd be confused about how he fucked up every time he did, and he'd never even know why Dave didn't like him, and every time Dave shoved him away he'd be helpless and lost to figure out why this alternate iteration of the person he admires most seems to hate him.]
[There's a pause. Because there are two ways to answer this, and both are true.]
I do think you're competent and not lame. You're a really cool person, in the ways that matter most, and you're really skilled and capable of handling a lot of different situations.
[That's way one.]
But I don't even think my baffled woundedness would have kept me from noticin' what an awkward, clumsy loser you are.
[That is actually an important clarification. It's nice.]
Yeah. Can't say I immediately felt the same, what with being busy wondering why you looked like you'd rather be dead than near me, but it came out later. [He can now joke about how Dave did not want to be near him. This is a good sign.]
It wasn't...super immediate with me, either. Just, like.
[ he shifts on the bed, restless. ]
When I stopped freaking out and started payin' attention.
[ "freaking out" here being just straight up not talking to dirk beyond a few stilted attempts at conversation and then wasting time not talking and trying to not engage with bro. ]
no subject
[ just...you know, any of the various trolls he has Not explained his life to. ]
no subject
Okay, so that's a reasonably possible outcome. Putting it aside, worst thing if he never finds out?
no subject
[ how to put it. ]
Bein' around him is like gettin' a straight shot of pure energy towards exactly what you always try to tear down. [ it's like being thirteen again and being around john makes it feel easy, the lies coming second-nature. ] If he never finds out...I don't know. I guess I'd just feel like crap sometimes for not tellin' him, but that's nothin' new and not comparable, I guess?
no subject
no subject
I. [ shit, he doesn't know? ] It felt easy. It was so easy.
no subject
[Backsliding isn't surprising.]
Backsliding is normal.
no subject
[ a quiet correction. ]
Sixteen years. On the meteor I like, thought about the things I did and why I did them. But I never talked about it. It was sixteen years of the same old mask.
no subject
Versus not even one.
no subject
[ deliberately going against his past. ]
But I don't think I'd be happy doing things the easy way with you, even if I've tried.
no subject
He doesn't know.]
Ignoring whether or not that was fucked up of me to think, what's the worst case scenario for you telling John? Without visualizing it. [No panic attack.]
no subject
He looks at me different.
no subject
You don't have to decide right now. You can wait.
no subject
[ on a sideways related note ]
no subject
[Since he'd be confused about how he fucked up every time he did, and he'd never even know why Dave didn't like him, and every time Dave shoved him away he'd be helpless and lost to figure out why this alternate iteration of the person he admires most seems to hate him.]
no subject
[ how to put it. ]
Competent and not lame? Which isn't a complaint about how you do see me.
no subject
I do think you're competent and not lame. You're a really cool person, in the ways that matter most, and you're really skilled and capable of handling a lot of different situations.
[That's way one.]
But I don't even think my baffled woundedness would have kept me from noticin' what an awkward, clumsy loser you are.
[And that's the other way]
no subject
[ it's the mildest protest in the history of the universe. and honestly, he likes that dirk can see who he is...usually.
though it never stops flustering him when dirk calls him cool in any way. in that way. ]
That helped. Back then. That you were, too.
no subject
[Since awkwardness isn't robotic terribleness.]
no subject
[ clarifying. ]
It wasn't like it was just that you weren't like Bro. You were like me.
[ it was a weird connection to have when it wasn't one he expected to ever get. ]
no subject
Yeah. Can't say I immediately felt the same, what with being busy wondering why you looked like you'd rather be dead than near me, but it came out later. [He can now joke about how Dave did not want to be near him. This is a good sign.]
no subject
[ he shifts on the bed, restless. ]
When I stopped freaking out and started payin' attention.
[ "freaking out" here being just straight up not talking to dirk beyond a few stilted attempts at conversation and then wasting time not talking and trying to not engage with bro. ]
And then I started noticing.
no subject
no subject
[ ............ranted about why he was, uh, not thrilled? ]
.............Had a moment.
[ there we go. ]
You reacted to the shit I was sayin'.
no subject
With my face muscles and everything.
[Dave must have been shocked when Dirk expressed any emotion at all, let alone shock about weapons in fridges.]
no subject
With my expressions.
[ a familiar turn of phrase. familiar minute reactions that bro had never displayed - dave had, though. ]
It was very much a twilight zone special?
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)